Taboo Socialism

by Curlydock

In 1949, Albert Einstein published an essay in the May issue of Monthly Review entitled “Why Socialism?”. The following is my take on what he said. His essay can be found on the Web at “”. I strongly recommend you read it. Your take might not be exactly the same as mine.

Now, as then, the terrible and subversive topic of socialism is “under a powerful taboo”. I agree with Einstein; we need to break this taboo.

He said it is important we express our views even if we are not experts in economics, science, philosophy, etc. I am taking him to heart here and now.

Economics, he said, is such a messy topic that it cannot be studied with rigor like other fields of science. Socialism is more an end than a means. While engineering, math and science might help us find a better way to an end, there is nothing they can really say about whether socialism should be our goal. We each will have to study, think, discuss with each other and come to our conclusions as best we can. As for myself, I have decided to abandon capitalism for socialism and to promote this decision. It is gratifying to know that a mind the caliber of Einstein’s would concur.

Einstein believed we are in a cultural crisis that is ultimately rooted in a self-contradiction in what it means to be a human being. Within each individual are conflicting needs. We need to both stand apart and stand together with others.

Our sense of freedom demands we go our own way. But the reality is that we cannot do without others. Somehow we came to see our individual interests as in conflict with the interests of society. Calm reflection tells us we are all in the same boat, but we still seem to need to assert ourselves over everyone else. How does this come about?

Is this internal conflict natural, from the time of birth, or is it something we learn from growing up in a culture devoted to greed and competition?

Einstein said there are no easy answers but for the sake of inner equilibrium we must try to orchestrate the demands of our contradictory nature. Unless a solution is found, a person cannot contribute significantly to society’s well-being.

In the development of solutions, we must hold faith that “nurture” can trump “nature”. We have memory and communication abilities that allow us to take charge of our development.

Anthropology has shown that cultural patterns are not fixed. We can choose our culture if we only will. Thinking and wanting can help determine what we will become, unlike ants and bees which are fixed in their cultures. This is a job for our imagination.

However, he said, while we may adjust some things to enhance life, some things that used to be possible will never be possible again. Man will never again be able to choose self-sufficiency as an individual or small group. To sustain the population level, we must continue to use the technologies that allowed the population to grow this large. We must continue to use extreme division of labor and large scale production if we are to satisfy our material needs. This must be done even in a socialist culture. Whatever else is possible, a global network of production and consumption must continue.

The root of our problems today, the source of evil, is the economic anarchy of capitalism. Workers are not paid based on the value of what they produce. They are paid only enough to keep them engaged to the process. The difference in value is taken by the owners of the means of production. This makes a parasite of the owner and a slave of the worker. Wealth accumulates to the few and the many are impoverished.

The intense concentration of wealth in a few hands nullifies democracy by corrupting the government, the press and the educational system. Competition, profit motive, and technological advancement keeps too many people unemployed. Selfish use of capital for the short term causes instability in the system which then cycles through periods of overproduction and underproduction; boom and bust.

Einstein said the worst evil of capitalism is the crippling of individuals. This comes early in life by an educational system geared to stress greed and competition above all else.

The only cure Einstein could see is a planned socialist economy and an educational system emphasizing social skills.

He cautioned, however, that a planned economy is not the same as socialism. True socialism is achieved only through the liberation of the individual. He said we must carefully avoid the centralization of power, whether it is based on government or business.

That is my take on Einstein’s essay.

I agree with most of it, but I wonder about the need to keep extreme division of labor, the current level of technology and a world-scale productive network. Our population, even larger now than when Einstein wrote, may already have passed a level that can be sustained even with the continued use of big and complicated production. These techniques have only worked in the short run by cheating in the accounting of all the costs to the environment and non-renewable resources. We may be on the verge of a very hard limit. On this I certainly hope I am wrong.

Dear reader, can you convince me otherwise? Did I make a mistake on my take of Einstein’s essay? Please feel very welcome to comment.

The URI to TrackBack this entry is:

RSS feed for comments on this post.

27 CommentsLeave a comment

  1. A very interesting read. I did not know Einstein also had his opinion on Socialism.

  2. Ray Creations:

    Thank you very much for your comment. It is the very first feedback from anyone on or off the internet regarding this particular post.

    Since the need for socialism is the largest thing on my mind today, I am particularly eager to communicate with others about it. But the taboo nature of it and other topics that interest me make me feel very lonely sometimes.

    While there may not be censorship outright, I quickly learned that if I want to keep a job, friends, and a family then I must be very good at stifling myself.

    What a spiritual desert our culture has become.

    Again, thanks.

  3. I haven’t visited your blog in many months, was doing some housekeeping on my Yahoo group Links and read this entry. I also had no idea Einstein weighed in on this topic. I also concur completely about the “tabooism” of the subject especially after the recent years of darkness (IMHO).

    As for the division of labor, and the “scale” question, I (among many) foresee an inevitable descent, based partially on the upcoming end of cheap fossil energy. In other words, a world where we will need more cobblers, and fewer derivative traders. I (think I) can tell by your blog entries that you are a “generalist”, and won’t allow your energies to be confined. I am always astounded at how many people feel comfortable with just “doing their job” and allow everything else (including thinking) to be done for them.

    Here’s an article you might find interesting about reskilling in anticipation of the change.

    I can appreciate the isolation you’re speaking of, and have the experience of folks around me not “getting it”. A lot of people haven’t awakened (TV helps a lot).

    I recently attended a meeting here in Louisville about the Transition Initiative and found kindred people who want to prepare. I’m not by nature a “group” person but I found this meeting inspirational. Here’s a link to their newly formed ning (whatever that is!) group.

    Also, some of us in the area are trying to educate ourselves an promote Permaculture training and practices in Louisville, and I would say that most of us feel the same unease about the way things are going that you seem to feel.

    I hope me entering these links is not inappropriate in your blog, I just wanted to let you know that there ARE other folks in this area.

    • ray:

      Thanks for your wonderful comment. It strengthens my hope.

      As long as they are appropriate, a couple of links are fine.

      Nor am I by nature a “group” person. I feel I should try to resist my isolationist predisposition. Note that Einstein addresses this when he speaks of the conflict or contradiction in our natures.

      Thanks again,

  4. Hi there just wanted to give you a quick heads up.
    The text in your post seem to be running off the screen in Safari.
    I’m not sure if this is a format issue or something to do with web browser compatibility but I figured I’d
    post to let you know. The design and style look great though!
    Hope you get the problem fixed soon. Many thanks

  5. In fact when someone doesn’t understand after that its up to other users
    that they will help, so here it takes place.

  6. Experian, unfortunately, car 0-60 times does not allow that, scoot right along to the
    client. A victimized object buyer should be given in a separate section of schedules.

    After the mechanic, you can go for a pre-owned
    car, don’t just take a salespersons word for it, but that raises the value of the car?
    This will determines how long and how far the car has been experienced by the
    current or previous owner.

  7. You actually make it seem so easy with your presentation however I in finding this topic to be really something that
    I believe I would by no means understand. It kind of feels too complicated and extremely broad for me.
    I am looking forward on your next submit, I will attempt
    to get the cling of it!

  8. You can certainly see your expertise within the work
    you write. The world hopes for even more passionate writers such as you who aren’t afraid to say how they
    believe. All the time follow your heart.

  9. Ensure the individual doing the drawing doesn’t chat and
    writing words or people is not permitted. Why do they like this type of free
    online games for girls? You can view the colors and labels of
    the polishes below.

  10. Roo’s new buddy Lumpy ties Pooh and his friends for
    Halloween in the 100-Acre Wood. A teen-age romantic comedy, 10
    Things I Hate About You is just a present day Taming of the Shrew.
    If you haven’t watched, please do!

  11. You have to change it into a PSP recognized extendable first.

    I wonder how I am going to handle through the remainder of the day.
    We discover a lady (or man) looking to pick out a true love among
    a dozen men (or women).

  12. Or are you content with the attributes the Iphone already
    brings to the desk? Occasionally when we are jailbreaking our gadget, data get misplaced.
    Even geeks have an image to uphold following all,
    and for them.

  13. In GTA 5 the total amount of adjustments players must choose from are
    various and common. Recall how I talked-about Monster Hunter being popular in China?
    Now that would impact my sanity, and our power consumption.

  14. Not only has this, by availing a contract mobile phone offer 1 gets a handset
    entirely free of cost. This is an easy-to-use app
    which comes at a cost of USD one.ninety nine.

  15. Simply click about the visit/support switch in the
    bottom of one’s program where your neighbors are stated there.
    The information to the wrapper rapidly turned my attention from
    chocolate for the cross of Christ.

  16. By doing so your phone gets to be a mini pc. Stage 7a:
    Unlocking only – In situation you are unlocking your 2g, select “unlock” because well.

    Select the Winterboard and use the specific theme which you want.

  17. Posséder de multiples btc par le trade facile

  18. I let them know simply they are the loves of my life and they’re used.
    This website gives some really cool Holiday games or activities.
    They’re ages 3 and 5, but they already know they
    are implemented.

  19. Today is the day to differentiate your future and your quality of life!
    Many who’ve created the dietary plan change alone
    have experienced considerable improvement in their diabetes.
    Today America is on the edge of self destruction.

  20. Le meilleur lissage capillaire bresilien en promo

  21. Apprenez a se procurer des bitcoins pas cher par le réseau internet sans effort

  22. L’excellent lissage bresilien keratine sur le réseau internet

  23. Decouvrez dépourvu atout prévoir la fleur cafetière expresso de manière à
    votre cuisine au crème loyer sur des sites internet.

  24. Excellent post! We will be linking to this particularly great
    content on our site. Keep up the good writing.

  25. Hmm is anyone else experiencing problems with the images on this blog loading?

    I’m trying to determine if its a problem on my end or if it’s the blog.
    Any feedback would be greatly appreciated.

  26. Odată ce ați înțeles de bucurie în curăție dumneavoastră , vă poate sau nu
    poate alege să împartă viața cu un alt . Atunci când se utilizează gât , ar trebui să încercați
    și să rulați ușor degetele de-a lungul se și sărută acest
    domeniu ușor .

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: