By Curlydock
Ever wonder what your sourdough starter gets up to when you are not looking? I spied on mine with a web-cam for about a day. Now I know the shocking truth of its secret life and will show and tell all in this installment.
Why care
about this? There are several parallels between what happens when you feed your sourdough starter and what has happened on this very planet Earth when the human population began to explode.
In both cases, there is a population of living things in an environment that is limited in size and resources.
The sourdough starter is populated with yeast and bacteria in symbiosis. It needs flour for the population to grow and will consume it all if you do not replenish it. Then, there is a die off or crash in the population as a result of starvation, resource exhaustion and poisoning by the accumulation of waste material. Sound familiar?
Earth is populated with people, all the species that people depend upon, and many species relegated to “weed” category, thought of as expendable because we have not yet figured out how to exploit them. Ecologists and those who understand the need for organic farming methods are among the precious minority who value species diversity. As much as we like to think we can dominate nature, the real truth is that we are also symbiots. Our determination to dominate instead of live in harmony is driving the planet and all its populations into a dead-end.
The sourdough starter cannot grow out of it’s jar. (Well, it can but is not likely to find more flour if it does.) The human population cannot leave this planet in any significant numbers any time soon. (And, even if it does, how much organic coffee can we grow on the moon?)
Perhaps the sourdough starter can teach us something about mindless consumption and procreation. “But”, you may protest, “Unlike yeast, people have minds!” I will counter: “A person in a state of denial behaves automatically and just as if they do not have a mind.” Mindless consumers. Purchase what you don’t need. Throw the left-overs in the gutter. Make babies like the world was going out of style. Well, perhaps it is.
The sourdough starter needs flour. Unless you replenish it, the starter will consume all that is available.
The human population of Earth has developed a crippling dependance on oil and other limited resources. Even if we don’t run out of coal and oil, we cannot continue to use them because their use in this already over-populated planet is what is triggering global warming. So, discovering vast new supplies of cheap oil is no solution. In fact, it could aggravate the real problem. Irony.
Procedure
I mixed 54 g of flour with 103 g of water. To that I added 68 g of vigorous starter. Of that 225 g total mixture, I poured 122 g into a glass jar and loosely coverd with a plastic lid. The glass jar was placed in a temperature controlled chamber in front of a camera. The temperature was monitored and never significantly deviated from 79 deg. or 80 deg. F. For a period of about 12 hours, one picture was taken every 5 minutes, resulting in 150 images.
Results
I selected eight of the 150 images to put here. In each image, you will see that I have inserted a set of numbers at the top center. These numbers represent the duration, in hours and minutes, at the time the image was recorded. So, the first image is “00:00”:
The next image is after 2 hours and 26 minutes have elapsed:
At 02:26 you see the normal layer of “hooch” forming. I did not know until I did this experiment that it first forms at the top of the starter. You also see the bubbles of gas forming in the starter, causing the starter to “rise” as it would when used to leaven bread dough. The hooch and gas are the waste products from the yeast and bacteia, the populations of which are beginning to grow rapidly.
At 03:16 the starter has risen a good bit. The hooch layer is
getting pushed to one corner as the center bulges.
At 03:26 there is another unexpected phenomenon.
The corner where the hooch was is foaming violently. I say violently because this all took place on a time scale of 5 or10 minutes. This is after almost an hour and a half of liesurly, predictable rise in the starter volume and number of gas bubbles (correlate with population of micro-organisms). I watched this occure on the monitor, bemoaning the fact that all this excitement would be lost to posterity because I had decided to record only one image every 5 minutes. I would have needed a couple of images a second to capture all this short-term activity, which began suddenly and without warning and did not last long at all. I gripped the edge of my seat and practically left greasy nose-marks on my monitor, wondering what this portended for my little microbe-cosm.
At 03:46 the foam is leaving. Where did the hooch go?
If you look closely you can see the hooch is now all the way at the bottom of the jar.
At 06:26 you see you can’t keep good hooch down.
Now there are three distinct layers. Under the hooch is a layer of starter that seems to be inactive because there are no bubbles in it. You can’t see it in a few images, but I can tell you it was still very active. Small chunks and particles were seen both rising and falling in the hooch layer. Since the bottom layer was growing, it must be that more was falling than rising. Does this remind you of the economy and the extinction of the middle class?
At 07:01 you can see the first settling of the top layer.
This tells us that the yeast and bacteria are beginning to die off. They have used up their resource (flour) and are now starving and succumbing to the poisonous effects of their waste products. It looks like the peak occured a bit after six hours in this experiment.
At 14 hours and 30 minutes I ended the experiment.
The top layer is at its lowest level since its peak. Once it started falling, the fall was pretty monotonous. I could have let it run longer but it had been a long day and this felt very much like the end of history.
Conclusion
Can we take any macro lessons from this micro-biological model? There are some important differences. Our planet, unlike the starter jar that got only one charge of flour, is being re-charged daily with “free” energy from the sun.
The trouble is, we have not been living within the energy budget of the sun since technology allowed us to exploit oil and greed made it inevitable. The energy density of “black gold” cannot be matched by solar, wind, geothermal, etc. Nuclear has a waste problem and the likelihood of catastrophic accidents increases with time and the number of reactors in use.
We may be running out of time to reverse the toxic byproduct of burning fossil fuels: global warming. It may be too late. It could accelerate tenfold or more without warning (remember the foam and the inversion of the hooch layer happened catastrophically). Indeed, there may be evidence of such an acceleration now, see: “Global Warming Already Causing Extinctions, Scientists Say“, by Hannah Hoag for National Geographic News, Nov. 28, 2006.
These sudden accelerations and unpredictable changes can happen in non-linear systems that are under stress. A little push in a certain direction causes changes that themselves add to the push and you get exponential acceleration. The hooch layer suddenly inverts. The die-off caused by global warming or the loss of oil as an energy source could also happen more quickly than predicted by the most dire of doomsayers.
Here is a very good reference for those interested in reading more on the topic of ecosystems that experience overshoot and sudden extinction: “Overshoot in a Nutshell” by David M. Delany.
[…] for Your Starter How sourdough bread works Sourdough Starter as Ecological Model The Zen of Sourdough Bethany’s Sourdough Saga Breadchick’s Yeast Beast Tips for a […]
While the webcam shots of your starter experiment were interesting your “eco-commentary” was a bit inane and factually incorrect.
Anatabaka
Anatabaka:
Thank you for your comment. In what way was the “eco-commentary” incorrect?
You left out something-GOD!
Anonymous spokesperson for God:
And how, do you think, would God figure in here?
Lol!! Curlydock, you are providing food, warmth, a living space and you decide if the microorganisms live a comfy life or get swept down the sink in an apocalyptic maelstrom. In this case aren’t you god? Anyway, Rod Serling would have been able to make a good Twilight Zone episode out of my above comment.
Good essay. I totally understand where you are coming from. You gave us an example of a closed system populated by a growing population of organisms who are nearing their carrying capacity, exceed it and die off. Comparing it to what is happening here on earth is absolutely reasonable. As we overpopulate the planet, we will deplete and foul our water, destroy our land, reach the limits of how much food we can grow and eventually have problems with disease.
mimi9:
Interesting angle. It did not occur to me that I was God in this experiment. Thanks for your input.
Curlydock
[…] for Your Starter How sourdough bread works Sourdough Starter as Ecological Model The Zen of Sourdough Bethany’s Sourdough Saga Breadchick’s Yeast Beast Tips for a Healthy […]
Hello; I arrived here indirectly from a search on biosand filters.
I have built one and have had it running for about 7 months. The water from it has been tested twice. The filter removes 99.9 percent of coliform bacteria including ecoli. I purposely ran very nasty roof water through it. I have recently installed a first flush diverter. The filter has been modified several times and is made mostly from recycled material. The website listed on this post has all the info. The filter cleans the water to a turbidity level equal to our well. These filters work and they are quite sustainable technology and indeed have been around for many years. I thought this might be of interest to others reading this site’s information.
Curlydock has checked out the site on small personal slow-sand water filter construction that Dave talks about in the previous comment. Curlydock highly recommends the site. To get to it, just go to Dave’s comment and click on “Dave” in that first line.
Dave; thanks so much for informing us about your filter experiments.
Very nice experiment. I arrived here searching for bread and hooch. Next time, you could take a pic every 30 seconds and then create a video of process. 🙂
Luiz:
The possibility of making a video from a time-lapse sequence did occur to me. Perhaps someday I will do that. But, I have so many other things I want to do; I may never get around to the video.
Mabey someone else will be inspired to make a video and publish their results. If they do, I hope they leave us a link here.
Thanks for your input.
Curlydock
[…] wasn’t sure if it wasn’t the sourdough bread i’d just baked from suspicious looking starter. but it seemed likely that it was the […]
where can I read about microcontroller in your blog?! I have searched about the word “atmel microcontroller” and you blog appeared to me
nitlogic:
Sorry, I really have no idea how “atmel microcontroller” brought you to this blog. I did a search on the term in my search box and came up with nothing. Perhaps it is a rather loose association to my bio due to the fact that I used to be an analog electronics engineer.
curlydock
Thanks for this, as a dyslic. Pitures so much easyer to read. b
Good way of explaining, and good article to take data about
my presentation focus, which i am going to present in institution of
higher education.
They will train you how to operate a dfop shipping business.
Shpping has created thousands of jobs through the world.
And as time passes from days to weeks and months, you could see
the trucking or motorcycle shipping inbdustry evolving a lot andd in this way you may find
value added services with this.
A strobe flash lies approximately an LED flash and a XENON flash.
Reason number-two: your iPhone may also upsurge in price, besides becoming more enjoyable to make use
of! This Can Be A free app from Barnes & Noble.
If you have diabetes it does not mean that you’ve to consume soft-food for the remainder of the life.
Atkins remains to be one of the very most common low-carbohydrate,
high-protein diets as a result of one reason.
There is no need to get software on your computer for revisions using the Browser.
Notice: jailbreaking your iPhone 3G might lead to it to become bricked or permanently ruined.
Your imagination for the ideal cell telephone becomes actuality with the Apple iphone.
This is 1 of the favorite ways that individuals personalize
their iPhones. Well, you don’t have to be concerned about that
anymore.
Put it up properly, take a bus, get off at a high rise, goto the 10th floor and throw it down the trash chute.
So you know which one’s are the best to observe. Find out how these young kids cope with
these zombies.
Absolutely nothing that you haven’t seen prior to,
really. All you need to do is to adhere to the instructions offered by the provider of jailbreak Iphone.
You don’t require to jailbreak your Iphone to use this application.
Kids may have pets, just like in almost any other digital earth.
Position points into each part with points in the tiny
core, as being a real dartboard.
Headphones are a crucial add-on every user must
have. You will manage to search them utilising the iPhone.
You must use custom IPSW to stop the baseband upgrade. Just
Google the AT&T site and go to the page.
With the help of jailbreaking you can get access to utilities,
games, tunes, apps, and toys. It can really do simple touch jailbreaks from old iPods and iPhones.
You can also see digital camera photos, etc.
You should use the TinyUmbrella application to truly
save the SHSH of your iPhone. It is black, and accessible
only in metallic gold. This software works with iPad, the
Apple iPhone and iPod Touch.
New programs will carry on to add performance and creativity to the device.
When faced with the challenge of choosing what to make for supper, I more and more flip
to my telephone. The Iphone 5G may come in white too.
Then what ipad 2 virtually provide to Mac enthusiasts? At this time we’re within the neutral range
and trying to increase! Itis so amazing you’ll find just two words
to explain it; pure master!
Your style is really unique compared to other people I have read stuff from.
Thanks for posting when you have the opportunity, Guess I’ll just bookmark
this web site.
There are 1000’s of programs that you can obtain in your
device. With the right electronics store on-line, you can get
the devices you want for a fair price. Yes! jailbreak is a easy and safe as well.
Heya i am for the first time here. I found this board and I find It truly helpful & it helped me out a lot.
I’m hoping to offer something again and aid others such
as you aided me.
Thanks a bunch for sharing this with all of us you really understand
what you’re speaking about! Bookmarked. Please additionally seek advice
from my website =). We may have a hyperlink alternate agreement
among us
Great blog here! Also your web site lots up fast! What host are you using?
Can I get your affiliate link on your host? I want my web site
loaded up as quickly as yours lol
You ought to take part in a contest for one of the best
websites online. I most certainly will recommend
this web site!
I got this website from my friend who shared with me on the topic of this web page and at the moment this time I
am browsing this site and reading very informative content at
this place.
You ought to take part in a contest for one of the greatest blogs online.
I will highly recommend this site!
It’s the best time to make some plans for the future and it is time to be happy.
I’ve read this post and if I could I wish to suggest you few interesting things
or advice. Maybe you could write next articles referring to this article.
I wish to read even more things about it!
I’m not sure why but this weblog is loading very slow for me.
Is anyone else having this issue or is it a issue on my end?
I’ll check back later on and see if the problem still
exists.
Oh my goodness! Incredible article dude! Thanks, However I am going through troubles
with your RSS. I don’t understand why I cannot subscribe to it.
Is there anybody else getting similar RSS issues?
Anyone that knows the solution can you kindly respond?
Thanks!!
Hmm it appears like your website ate my first comment (it
was super long) so I guess I’ll just sum it up what I wrote
and say, I’m thoroughly enjoying your blog. I as well am an aspiring blog blogger but I’m still new to the whole thing.
Do you have any tips for first-time blog writers? I’d definitely appreciate it.
Pretty part of content. I just stumbled upon your website and in accession capital to claim that I get actually loved account your blog
posts. Anyway I’ll be subscribing on your augment and even I fulfillment you
get admission to constantly rapidly.